California Literary Review

Movie Review: Legion


January 23rd, 2010 at 1:03 pm

  • Print Print
Movie Poster: Legion

Directed by Scott Stewart
Screenplay by Peter Schink, Scott Stewart

Michael – Paul Bettany
Jeep Hanson – Lucas Black
Kyle Williams – Tyrese Gibson
Charlie – Adrianne Palicki
Percy – Charles S. Dutton
Gabriel – Kevin Durand
Bob Hanson – Dennis Quaid
Gladys Foster – Jeanette Miller
Ice Cream Man – Doug Jones

CLR Rating: ★½☆☆☆

Movie Still: Legion

Paul Bettany stars in Legion
Photo By: Lewis Jacobs. ©2008 Bold Films LP. All Rights Reserved

The Apocalypse on a Tight Budget

Good horror movies are rare. This year’s second scary movie (following last week’s Daybreakers) is certainly not one of them. As a nation we seem preoccupied at the moment with the apocalypse. This fad comes and goes often, but with 2012 (the end of the Mayan calendar and the date of the supposed prophesied apocalypse) looming on the horizon, studios are banking on our social anxieties—which are already high due to the recession, our political climate and the threat of terrorism. Legion doesn’t present the same kind of apocalypse depicted in the movie 2012’s trailers (which seem to show the whole world literally falling apart), but it is the End of Days nonetheless.

According to the script, God has lost faith in humanity, ostensibly because he grew “tired of all the BS.” Thus He orders the angels to exterminate mankind—just to switch it up a bit, since last time He went with a flood. The angel Michael (Paul Bettany) disagrees with God’s order and falls from heaven to save the human race. Michael chooses a tiny town called Paradise Falls (a clever but gauche touch of Dante), at the edge of the Mojave desert, in which to prove that humans are worth saving. Michael’s been keeping an eye on homely Jeep (Lucas Black) and pregnant, single Charlie (Adrianne Palicki) for years, and has pegged them as proof that humans are worth saving. In particular, Charlie’s unborn child is lined up to be the savior—although this is never quite explained. Bad fortune brings a number of strangers to the diner at which the two work and live, and there the battle plays out.

In Legion, God is neither infallible nor merciful. The angels are not lovely and ethereal—no halos for these soldiers. Instead they are dark, cruel minions who inhabit humans to ensure the End of Days. This might’ve been an effective take on the Biblical apocalypse if it weren’t for the ridiculous special effects. Before the battle gets underway, a very old woman with a walker comes into the diner, all smiles and sweetness. Unfortunately, the trailers already revealed that she’s evil, and sloppy filmmaking creates such ominous foreshadowing (elongated shadows, stalker view—from behind rather than ahead) that the audience simply lies in wait for her to do something nutty, which of course she does. In The Exorcist III, an elderly woman in a mental hospital (who happens to be possessed) crawls on the ceiling behind the characters’ heads, and it’s one of the most unsettling moments in the film. Legion’s effects budget evidently didn’t cover anything that looks realistic, and as such the audience guffawed at a moment that should have been disturbing. When the special effects of a movie made twenty years ago trump one made last year, there’s a problem. Shortly thereafter, an ice cream truck appears, cheerily amplifying that song so familiar to kids in the summertime. The ice cream man, played by Doug Jones, whose acting is most recognizable by his magnificently exacted bodily movements (he was Abe Sapien in the Hellboy movies as well the Silver Surfer in the eponymous movie) is supremely underutilized when the terrible CGI takes over.

The film’s script is fairly run of the mill. It’s funny at times, but leaves characters completely undeveloped—a technique best used in movies like the original Texas Chain Saw Massacre—the difference being that at least Chain Saw’s rather deplorable, one-dimensional characters had some really horrifying death scenes. Most of the murders in Legion are not typical of the horror genre, which mostly relies on hand-to-hand combat: knives, chainsaws, and other weapons. Guns and explosions are plentiful in Legion, which nearly crosses into the action realm. Though it has a dearth of good computer imagery, the makeup effects and gore are well done. The movie’s rated R for violence and language, and rightfully so, but a curious aspect of the film is that a few of the “good” characters smoke cigarettes, one while pregnant. The MPAA decided in 2007 that any amount of smoking in a movie automatically raises its rating, so it’s interesting to see a focus on cigarettes in a culture that’s becoming less tolerant of the habit.

Legion is an effects-laden and silly movie that tells yet another rendition of the apocalypse in which the Christian God smites mankind for our numerous sins. Whether or not you believe the apocalypse is upon us, this is an especially farfetched version of events, entertaining but neither new nor particularly well told; loose ends and underdeveloped characters abound. Paul Bettany is a pleasure to watch in any medium, and Adrianne Palicki may be headed for a healthy film career (her role in TV’s “Friday Night Lights” showed she is in fact quite talented). However, the movie isn’t worth seeing in theaters unless you want to spend an evening chuckling and cringing.

Legion Trailer

  • James Street

    Unfortunately, movies like Legion are not worthy of a view OR a review.

    People who are niche-movie-market targets (about 99.97% of the population) will like them anyway, no matter what you say about them.

    But an intelligent deconstruction of the juvenile, disjointed and cynical characterizations and plotting of a movie like Legion could hold a valuable mirror up to “the culture.”

    You show every sign of being able to construct such a mirror but you seem to be caught in the footlights of the need to have an audience, and I don’t blame you for being paralyzed.

    To get many readers most people simply join the dark side, drink the cool aid and eat the Cheez-Its. Very few people, such as Tom Wolfe, are capable of being in the crowd but not of it.

    I would love to see you jettison your vox populi ballast and sail unencumbered into the high seas of real culture, whatever you decide that it is.

    The old French proverb is relevant: Qui se ressemble s’assemble.

  • ipodmovies

    I can’t wait to see this movie. It looks great!

  • James Street

    Confusas estaban la ventera y su hija, y la buena de Maritornes, oyendo las razones del andante caballero, que así las entendían como si hablara en griego

  • GTG

    I really did not like this movie since it was not done the way it’s going to happen. Their is a time that God will judge those who don’t believe. Michael the archangel never fights with Gabriel the angel in the past nor in the future, read the Bible and it will show you the truth.

  • David Loftus

    GTG’s comment is scarier than anything I can imagine seeing in this movie. Pray to God it’s intended as a joke.

  • J

    David – I’m certainly hoping so. Hrm.

  • Andy


    Low budget, boring, and nothing like promised…
    just a bunch of people out at a truck stop shooting guns at some bad guys.

    Where is the big angel battle depicted on the front cover? A massive fraud of movie marketing on the slowest movie ever. What a waste of $5.99 for the rental.

Get The Latest California Literary Review Updates Delivered Free To Your Inbox!

Powered by FeedBlitz

Recent Comments